If geeks love it, we’re on it

Thermaltake MEKA mechanical gaming keyboard review

Thermaltake MEKA mechanical gaming keyboard review

ThermalTake MEKA keyboard review

To most people, a keyboard is often one of the last pieces of a computer to be considered. If a portion of the budget is even reserved for a keyboard, it’s a very tiny amount—sometimes less than $20. It’s kind of odd too, especially considering the amount of use keyboards get.

Of course there is an exception to this generality: the aficionado. The keyboard aficionado knows the differences between types of keyboards right down to the very components. They can tell you what makes a great keyboard great as well as why “that other keyboard” isn’t worthy of their attention. Likewise, they are willing to shell out obscene amounts of money for the keyboard that best suits their needs as well as their desires.

For gamers who demand more from their input devices, Thermaltake offers the MEKA line of mechanical keyboards.

The Thermaltake MEKA is a compact version of the MEKA G1 Phil reviewed a while back. It falls under Thermaltake’s Tt eSPORTS line of products. Its listed features are:

  • Up to 1000MHz polling rateMEKA keyboard keyswitches
  • Cherry Black mechanical switches
  • Two USB 2.0 ports
  • Anti-Ghosting function (up to 16 keys)
  • Gold-plated teeth connectors
  • 1.8m Braided cable
  • Smart cable management
  • Switch lifecycle: 50 Million
  • Dimensions (LxWxH): 16.93×6.3×1.57 inches (370x150x35 mm)

Everything about this keyboard says “heavy duty”. Given the wrong circumstances it could probably be used as a weapon or shield. The keyboard itself has a very good heft to it—far heavier than I expected a keyboard that size could be. The braided USB cable is extremely thick, but surprisingly bendable.

The only lights on the MEKA are on the Scroll Lock, Num Lock, and Caps Lock keys. Small windows at the bottom center of each are just big enough to show a small amount of red light indicating on/off status.

As a travel keyboard, the MEKA is awesome. It fits very nicely in my SLAPPA backpack (something my G15 just cannot do) and still leaves room for tons of other gear. Smaller laptop bags will easily hold the keyboard as well. The keyboard includes a Velcro tie that keeps the USB cable nicely wrapped during travel.

Mice should slide, keyboards should stay in place. The MEKA’s anti-skid pads are very effective at making sure the keyboard stays right where you want it. Four pads contact the desk, and this seems to be enough for a solid hold. It can be moved, but you pretty much have to want to move it to do so.

The guts of the MEKA

The Cherry MX Black keyswitches are fantastic. This my first experience in a very long time with a mechanical keyboard, and I’m sold. The tension on the keys is even for the entire keystroke, and the resistance just feels right. The feel of the “other” style with its mushy rubber domes just doesn’t feel as good anymore.

Top view of the MEKA keyboard

The layout. Mostly normal, but missing a key.

I do have one complaint, and it has to do with the layout. The backspace key is reduced to normal key size, the question mark key is now to the right of the up arrow key, and there isn’t a Windows key at all. The first two can be worked around—it’s just a matter of learning the new layout. The missing Windows key is a bit more problematic for me—many useful shortcuts are now lost. While less than optimal, the left control key could have been cut down a bit to accommodate the Windows key, but it is what it is.

Using the MEKA

Icrontic Stamp of Approval BronzeGaming with the MEKA is a very satisfying experience. The keyboard is very comfortable even during extended gaming sessions. I’m mostly an FPS gamer, and I couldn’t find anything to complain about during the hours spent testing under Team Fortress 2 and Deus Ex: Human Revolution. My exposure to the MMO world is nil, but given the keyboard’s ability to handle 16 simultaneous keys, and the same excellent internals as the MEKA G1, it’s not a stretch to predict good results.

In my dual roles of software engineer and Icrontic writer, it’s not uncommon to spend upward of 14 hours at the keyboard in a day. Despite the MEKA’s slightly odd layout and missing shortcut key, it still works well for both roles. And I’ll admit, I’m now sold on the virtues of mechanical keyboards. Were it not for the cost of replacing all the keyboards in my house with mechanical versions, I’d do it in a heartbeat.

The Thermaltake MEKA sells for $100.99 on Newegg before a $20 mail-in rebate. It’s expensive when compared to other keyboard types, but narrowing the field down to mechanical keyboards of its type (using Cherry MX Black switches), the price is actually on the low end of the spectrum. Additionally, the keyboard is very well built and should last a very long time. An extra $10 will get you the MEKA G1, but if you need a quality compact keyboard, the Thermaltake MEKA is definitely a keyboard to consider and is awarded the Icrontic Stamp of Approval.

Comments

  1. BuddyJ
    BuddyJ dibs. I want clicky keys.
  2. Ryan I use Win+D and Win+E far too often to give them up. I do want to try a mechanical keyboard for gaming. I use an old one at work and I find I type much faster due to the feedback.
  3. RootWyrm
    RootWyrm
    Ryan wrote:
    I use Win+D and Win+E far too often to give them up. I do want to try a mechanical keyboard for gaming. I use an old one at work and I find I type much faster due to the feedback.

    Both the Meka and Meka G1 use the same Cherry Black switches, which do not click. The noise I produce on a Meka G1 is actually me bottoming out the keycaps. I could compare them both to any number of keyboards in terms of feel, but it all ends up being subjective. If you're used to an IBM Model M, though, I can more or less guarantee that the tactile feedback of any keyboard with Cherry Black switches will leave you wanting. (No exceptions, it's not just these two. It's the nature of the switch.) You want Cherry Blues, which click mechanically and audibly.

    The one big drawback of the Meka G1 is that even though it does have a Windows key, it's on the right, between Ctrl and Alt. The G1 does have an ISO layout including properly sized backspace and enter keys, but the left 'Windows' key is actually the Fn key - does not work the same, at all. Having handled several other Cherry Black models, other than cost, most of the faults of the Meka G1 are easy to look past if you like the feel. The keycaps last MUCH longer than any of the coated ones. But the ghosting is much harder to look past, as is the pricetag. Telling you how long your keycaps will last is voodoo by and large, but mine were slippery and shiny within 4 months. Which has to be stacked against 1991 Model M13's, where I chew up the same key positions about every 9 to 12 months. YMMV - I drop 50K words a day easily, 7 days a week. BUt you can get replacements pretty easily, so don't let it be a major holdup.

    In the world of upcoming mechanicals, you need to be watching Corsair for two models. First up, Vengeance K60. Cherry RED switches full board, and an aluminum housing. Tres chic. Very FPS oriented, but you'll find a use for it. MRSP of $110. Next up will be the Vengeance K90, which is MMO/RTS oriented. Reset expectations: aluminum chassis, Cherry Red primary, rubber dome ancillary, 18 programmable keys, ISO layout, dedicated function keys, onboard memory for macros, full-matrix anti-ghosting. I can tell you right now, it's going to shock a lot of people. (Good and bad ways.)
  4. Tim
    Tim After reading reviews and watching youtube videos, and trying a Razer keyboard at Best Buy with Cherry Blue switches in it, I decided I wanted Cherry Brown switches in the mechanical keyboard I got. I ended up finding an Xarmor U9 on newegg with the brown switches and I got it for $80 and I like it a lot. Only 2 very minor problems - it doesn't have a USB hub built in, and the higher priced version of the U9 that does have the USB hub also has Cherry Blue switches, and after only a month or so, the letters on my WASD keys are faded a bit. Other than that it is great and more fun to use than the almost 10 year old Dell keyboard I was using before this U9.
  5. BuddyJ
    BuddyJ Balls. Thanks Phil for the info. I didn't realize they were Cherry Blacks. Those Corsair keyboards sound hot though.
  6. mertesn
    mertesn For anyone wondering what we're talking about when referring to "Cherry Black/Brown/Blue/etc", this link offers a great explanation.
  7. Cliff_Forster
    Cliff_Forster I'm pleased to see the market embracing mechanical keyboards as true performance models. I've been put off by the marketing trend of taking a cheap keyboard, back-lighting it, putting a few macro keys on it and charging $80 for it. Real performance comes from the quality of the build, and you just can't build a true quality lasting keyboard without a good set of mechanical switches. If you are kind to one of these, clean it regularly, don't spill on it, you can type on it for a decade, and it will feel nearly identical to the first day you got it.

    As far as to what color Cherry MX to favor, they are all really nice. I think there is a trend to the blacks and browns just because most users don't care for the clicky sound the other variations present. The blacks don't need to bottom out when you double tap them, so some say they are better for gaming. I type so heavy either way, it barely matters for me, but any way you go, it's going to beat the heck out of any cheap rubber domed keyboard you have likely been using.
  8. cherplunka
    cherplunka really looking forward to seeing more about those corsairs, i've been ogling the black widow ultimate a while now for myself.
  9. primesuspect
    primesuspect We'll have the Corsair K60 up for review soon :D
  10. Cliff_Forster
    Cliff_Forster
    We'll have the Corsair K60 up for review soon :D

    Do Want!

    I've never used a board with Cherry MX Red's, I'll be anticipating the review.
  11. PirateNinja
    PirateNinja
    mertesn wrote:
    For anyone wondering what we're talking about when referring to "Cherry Black/Brown/Blue/etc", this link offers a great explanation.

    God bless you.
  12. Tim
    Tim I like my choice of Brown switches, but it'd be nice if they had heavier springs in them, 45 grams is a bit too light for me. Maybe 70-80 grams would be good. I guess the Cherry Clears would be the closest thing, but I haven't found any keyboards using them. It's all Black, Brown, and Blue.

    I'd also like to get a spare Caps Lock key for my U9 and cut the right half of it off, as I hit the Caps Lock all the time when typing at any kind of speed and hitting A.

    Has anyone noticed that I'm actually WITH the group on a piece of new technology for once? :)
  13. Tim
    Tim Also, even though these keyboards advertise USB polling rates of up to 1000 Hz, the default rate in XP is only 125 Hz. I found a program to raise my polling rate to 500 Hz, but I had to uninstall SP3 and go back to SP2 to use it. It helped my mouse sensitivity in Starcraft 2, I had to adjust the settings a bit.
  14. PirateNinja
    PirateNinja I heard you had to revert to IE6 to fully take advantage of PS2 keyboard polling rates.
  15. primesuspect
    primesuspect Tim, I wish you would come to Expo or something one year. We all need to meet you.
  16. Tim
    Tim Pay for my plane ticket, rental car, hotel room, food, etc, and it is a possibility. :)
  17. primesuspect
    primesuspect Nah, don't want to meet you THAT badly :p
  18. TheAlertHusky I do kind of want this keyboard because I'm stuck with an asus chicklet keybo. Which don't get me wrong is pretty great but there are some squeaks that can get annoying if don't have any sound but it's not crippling or anything.
  19. Tom B This keyboard looks great if I wanted to play games 8 years ago... and pressing the windows key was something that anyone still did by accident.

Howdy, Stranger!

It looks like you're new here. If you want to get involved, click one of these buttons!