Titan TTC-CU5TB Heatsink Review

MediaMan (MediaMan) One look through the Titan website and one fact stands out. Titan produces quiet cooling solutions for both AMD and Intel processors with not one heatsink generating over 33 dB(A). The Titan TTC-CU5TB may look "cool" but looks can be deceiving.

February 11, 2003 1:47 AM ET in Review,

Supplied by titan


wsbox

One look through the Titan website
and one fact stands out. Titan produces quiet cooling solutions for both AMD
and Intel processors with not one heatsink generating over 33 dB(A). The Titan
TTC-CU5TB may look “cool” but looks can be deceiving.

wsheatsink

Specifications:



























































 
External appearance








  Length : 72 mm








  Width : 72 mm








  High : 59.2 mm
  Copper color
 
Fan








  Dimensions : 70 x 70
x 15 mm








  Rated Voltage : 12 V DC








  Rated Current : 0.27 A








  Power Consumption : 3.24 W








  Rated Speed : 4,500 RPM








  Max Air
Flow
: 36.31 CFM








  Max Static
Pressure
: 5.26 mm-H size=1>2O








  Noise Level : < 32
dBA








  Tolerance : ¡Ó 10 %








  Bearing
Type
: Ball Bearing








  Life Time : 50,000 Hours
  Housing   3 Wires, 3 Pin Connector
  Interface   Silver Thermal Grease

  • Pure Copper CPU cooler AMD Duron / Thunderbird (Socket
    A / 462) up to 1.4 GHz, Athlon XP 2800+
  • The part of the fan frame’s materials is Aluminum
  • Copper Heatsink & Copper clip with Aluminum frame
  • Heat sink dimensions : 72 x 72 x 38 mm
  • Total dimensions : 72 x 72 x 59.2 mm

The Heatsink

The Titan TTC-CU5TB is a copper CPU cooler and features a narrow footprint.

wsheatsink

The 3-socket ear clip design lessens the stress on the motherboard socket.

clipa

clipb

It is a two piece clip and it may be, as with most heatsink clips, a bit awkward
to mount if the motherboard is already in place inside the PC case. The best
route is to mount the heatsink before installing the motherboard. This gives
the most working room but if need be the Titan TTC-CU5TB installs relatively
easily.

Depending on the motherboard it is the capacitors which present most problems
to heatsink installation and not the heatsink itself.

tightmount

The deception

The deception is the false covering on the heatsink base.

bottomheatsink1

It would be presumptuous to assume that the sticker peels off revealing the
customary “pink goop” thermal paste. You couldn’t be more wrong. Take
a closer look.

cucovering

The heatsink base is covered with a protective covering layer which peels off
revealing an absolutely mirror finish.

peeloff

The Titan TTC-CU5TB is extremely well finished. The distortion effect is only
the reflection of the curtains on the wall.

mirrorfinish3

Titan also includes a tube of their silver grease.

silvergrease

Once the protective covering is peeled off be cautious in handling the heatsink
to avoid your “grubby little fingerprints” and causing any unnecessary
scratches.

The 24 fins are protected by the fan mount housing. It appears as though there
is a pipe running through the fins but in actuality it is the fins which have
been punched and then fit together. The pun acts like a spacer and thus forms
the illusion of a pipe.

fins

Finally the fan itself is a 70×70x15mm. Titan Aluminum Frame fan that generates
36.31 CFM at less than 32 dB(A) with a rotational speed of 4,500 RPM.

frontfan

backfan

Note that only the frame is aluminum and the blades and core are plastic as
well as the motor mount. Airflow direction is INTO the heatsink in its stock
configuration.

Titan was good enough to send TWO Titan TTC-CU5TB heatsinks so that Short-Media
could torture them on a dual AMD 2100+ MP Gigabyte 7DPXDW-P board. Dual processor
systems run notoriously hotter than their single processor counterparts and
due to that more effective cooling is needed.

Twice the coolers also means twice the noise therefore less than 32 dB(A) is
welcome.

The competition was my trusted companion throughout every system I’ve built;
the Globalwin WBK38. This workhorse aluminum cooler was modified to carry a
92mm. Sanyo Denki fan pushing a massive 50 CFM at only 36 dB(A).

WBK38w92mmSD

The GlobalWin CAK4-76T has a built-in temperature
sensor to speed regulate the 70 x 70 x 15 mm fan. At 30 degrees Celsius the
minimum airflow is 23.1 CFM at 24.7 dBA and at 38 degrees Celsius the maximum
airflow is 36 CFM at 35 dBA.

CAK4-76Tfrontclip

The CAK4-76T is very similar in design and fan specifications pumping out the
same 36 CFM at 35 dB(A) which is only 3 dB(A) greater.

Let’s get an orientation of the system. The top right or upper processor is
CPU A and the bottom right or lower processor is CPU B. It’s very important
to keep track of this and here’s why. CPU B sits directly above the Matrox Parhelia
512 video card which deflects some airflow and, most importantly, generates
a lot of heat. (You’ll singe your fingers on the memory chips…really)

cufaninstalled

That heat from the video goes straight up into CPU B creating higher temperature
readings than CPU A.

The test system and benchmarks

• 2 x AMD 2100+ MP Palomino Processors

• Gigabyte GA-7DPXDW+ Motherboard (version P)
• 60 GB Maxtor ATA133 7200 RPM HDD
• 1 x 60 GB Maxtor ATA133 7200 RPM HDD
• Matrox Parhelia 512 video card
• 2 x 512 MB Micron PC2100 RAM (AT7)
• 4 x 256 Crucial Reg ECC
• Sony 52x CD
• LG 48×24x40x CDRW
• 2 x Samsung 950p 19″ Monitors
• USB Keyboard and Logitech USB wireless Optical Mouse
• Globalwin CAK4-76T HSF
• AMK PC75 modded PC case (window, fans, cables, loom)
• Enermax 465 Watt FC PSU
• Windows XP Professional SP1

The system was allowed to idle for 1/2 hour before
and after tests to establish a nominal case temperature. All fans were disengaged
except for the PSU fan and heatsink fans. Ambient room temperature was 23.2
degrees Celsius.

It is very important to remember that these are
MP processors which run considerably warmer than XP processors. Temperature
readings in your own system will vary due to room temperature, processor used
and if additional case fans are employed.

The tests were conducted with the stock heatsink configurations and then with
an 80mm. Titan Aluminum frame fan on the Titan TTC-CU5TB heatsinks. The 82×82x25mm.
Titan aluminum frame fans generate 38.22 CFM at less than 29 dB(A). The reason
for this modification will be explained.

Sisoft Sandra 2002 CPU burn ran 50 consecutive times for CPU Arithmetic and
Multimedia tests to attain a peak load temperature.

temperaturetests

Conclusion

A few things can be determined by looking at the graphs. The overspill of air
from the 92mm. fan on the WBK38 creates a superior cooling effect on system
board temperatures. Moving to a larger and higher CFM fan does not create superior
cooling though it does reduce overall noise level. This is due to the 82mm.
fan overlapping the heatsink opening to the fins thus some airflow is blocked
and cooling efficiency is lost.

The Globalwin CAK4 and Titan TTC-CU5TB are fairly evenly matched heatsinks
for specifications. Both have 70×70x15mm. fans that generate the same CFM but
one might think that the CAK4-76T would be louder due to the fact that it runs
at 35 dBA when the Titan runs at less than 32 dB(A).

The amount of sound coming from the CAK4-76T may be greater but the pitch of
the Titan TTC-CU5TB was higher thus making the Titan heatsink more intrusive
on the ears. Quite simply it gave the illusion that it was louder even though
the strength of the noise level was less for dB(A) rating.

Dual processor systems are quite finicky for heatsinks and the processor nearest
the video card will always be a few degrees warmer due to the video card generating
heat and blocking some airflow. This was quite apparent in the tests.

Aesthetically the Titan TTC-CU5TB looks great in a Lian Li case. The aluminum
frame fan with the faux aluminum blades matches well and reflects lighting magnificently.

ecufaninstalled

caselit2

Sadly I did expect a less than 32 dB(A) fan to be quieter. The look of the
Titan TTC-CU5TB is most certainly pleasing in an aluminum case. Overclockers
will want to avoid the Titan TTC-CU5TB as it doesn’t have the ability to handle
high loads.

As a final note when additional case cooling was employed via two rear exhausts,
two front intakes and a side intake the idle temperatures dropped to 50 degrees
Celsius for CPU A and 55 degrees Celsius for CPU B. This is an important point
to remember when cooling today’s processors.

wsheatsink

 

Our thanks to Titan
for supplying the Titan TTC-CU5TB samples.

Highs

  • All copper heatsink design.
  • Aluminum frame fan.
  • 3-ear clip design.
  • Small base footprint.
  • Mirror finish.
  • Looks cool in an aluminum PC case.

Lows

  • Deceivingly loud fan.
  • Stiff clip.
  • Not for overclockers.