Icrontic’s ultimate HTPC – Holiday 2009 edition

Brian Ambrozy (primesuspect) Icrontic presents its 2009 Holiday HTPC guide, highlighting high performance entertainment technology while remaining optimistically budget-minded.

November 3, 2009 2:44 PM ET in Articles, , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , , ,

Netflix integration in Windows Media Center 7

Netflix integration in Windows Media Center 7

The HTPC, or Home Theater PC, has been an elusive beast. For years, people have bandied about the concept of building a PC that is a dedicated home entertainment hub rather than a general-purpose computer. Up until very recently, building an HTPC has been a difficult journey to find the sorcerous combination of parts and software that would enable exactly everything one wanted the PC to do.

Luckily, everything has recently started coming together. Retail availability of key technologies such as efficient power supplies, cool and quiet processors, HDMI-enabled and 1080p-capable GPUs, massive storage capacities, and–perhaps most importantly–an HTPC-optimal OS have all come together in a ballet of technology which can provide a seamless and graceful HTPC experience.

We have put together an amazingly high performance and relatively low cost HTPC just in time for the 2009 holiday season. While we did operate with a liberal cost philosophy when it came to component choices, we feel that this remains an affordable project for those in the market for a full-featured home entertainment hub.

We’ve had this system running at our office for a few weeks now, and we’ve been hard pressed to find a task that it cannot handle. Our HTPC has even proven somewhat capable with gaming; it could easily handle any game on the market if we added a good discrete GPU to it.

The core of the system is the Vision platform: The seamless union of an AMD processor, chipset, and GPU. AMD has really pushed the platform ideology lately, and it has become quite impressive for feature-built PCs such as this. To that end, we’re switching it up from last year’s Intel Core 2 setup to a system built around AMD components.

AMD’s 2006 acquisition of ATI is clearly beginning to bear fruit, as the ingredients of the Vision platform show a definite technological cooperation that is simply not possible with parts from disparate manufacturers.

All of our testing was done at 1080p (1920×1080) resolution on an HDMI-equipped Samsung HDTV and a Logitech THX-certified 2.1 sound system.

Motherboard

The Gigabyte MA785GPMT-UD2H mainboard.

The foundation of our HTPC is the motherboard. We received a Gigabyte MA785GPMT-UD2H as a review sample and figured it to be a low-budget, low-feature micro-ATX socket AM3 board. We were wrong. It is indeed low budget, but it carries the AMD 785G chipset, uses high-endurance solid capacitors, and is made with 2oz of solid copper in the PCB; the board has a heft and solidness that we’ve never seen in a micro-ATX board.

The MA785GPMT-UD2H is the most full-featured budget motherboard we’ve ever had on our test bench. It supports up to 16GB of DDR3 RAM, and it has the amazing ATI Radeon 4200 IGP for video, which delivers HDMI, DVI and D-sub out connections.

This board also sports an 8-channel Realtek DSP with optical SPDIF output. Connectivity is rounded out with an eSATA port, 6x USB ports, a gigabit Ethernet controller, and a 1394 port. With this board in your HTPC, you only need three cables to hook everything up: A power cord, an Ethernet cord, and an HDMI cable.

PRICE: $94.99 from Newegg.

Processor

amd-athlon-ii-pib-imageWe chose the AMD Athlon II X4 620 as the brains of this little operation. It’s basically a Phenom II without L3 cache–something you really won’t notice in your home theater tasks. This little four core wonder (notably, the first quad core CPU for under $100) handily powered through all encoding and decoding tasks we threw at it.

At 95W TDP, the 620 represents the ideal balance between performance and economical power consumption. We briefly toyed with using one of the “e” series Athlon IIs for this project, but decided that the extra speed provided by the 620 was worth the additional 40 watts of TDP. Even at a “gluttonous” 95W, this machine will still dissipate less heat than, say, a Playstation 3 or an Xbox 360.

Also: we have it on good authority that this thing can be overclocked very easily, even on the stock cooler.

PRICE: $99.00 from Newegg.

Memory

OCZ Gold

We can’t lie: OCZ has been a great friend to Icrontic over the years, and we have no trouble recommending their memory for this project. It would be easy for us to say “no way, let’s jock some other memory company” if OCZ would just… Screw up for once. You know, release a shoddy product, make some overpriced piece of garbage, or have terrible support or crappy warranties. Unfortunately, they keep avoiding all of that and consistently produce excellent hardware at a compelling price. It’s very frustrating for us.

The only thing we don’t like about OCZ is their infernal insistence on sticking with mail-in rebates for their compellingly low prices. We’d rather see direct discounts, as MIRs are a pain in the ass for the consumer and manufacturer. OCZ, give it up!

At any rate, the 4GB OCZ Gold AMD Edition kit provides a solid amount of RAM for this box. Even when transcoding 1080p video while surfing the web and playing music, we never got above 2.4GB of RAM usage. Right now, 4GB is the definite price/performance sweet spot, and OCZ fits that bill.

PRICE: $83.99 from Newegg after a $20 MIR.

Graphics

This represents a major departure from the norm here. For the first time ever, we recommend sticking with onboard video for one of our builds. The ATI Radeon 4200 IGP is a marvel: A truly capable, DirectX 10.1-compliant GPU that just happens to be soldered onto a motherboard. We had our doubts, even as we fired up Team Fortress 2 at 1920×1080. Though, admittedly, all settings had to be cranked to low, but the game was perfectly playable.

The motherboard we chose provides 128mb of onboard DDR3 1333mhz RAM dedicated to the GPU. You can allocate more from your system RAM if you so choose, but for theater tasks, this is unnecessary.

Even more impressively, we’ve watched the Radeon 4200 IGP obliterate theĀ  NVIDIA GeForce 9600 GT in hardware-accelerated H.264 encoding. While it is certain that almost any modern discrete GPU will facepound the 4200 in gaming tasks, we’re not here to game–we’re here to do media, and the 4200 excels at this.

In addition, the 785G chipset supports Hybrid CrossFireX. Stick a low-end discrete Radeon HD card into the PCIe slot, and it’ll help with 3D rendering so you can improve your gaming. In all honesty, with the prices of the new 5000-series, we don’t see much use for this, but it’s there if you want it.

PRICE: Included in the motherboard

Power supply

The OCZ Z Series 650W.

The power supply is an oft-overlooked piece in an overall system build, and it absolutely shouldn’t be. It’s hard to feel romance towards the lowly PSU because it doesn’t make your computer run faster, make more polygons show up, or make your system look better. It’s an ugly square wart with a glob of cables dangling from it that we hide away behind computer panels. Still, choosing the PSU is one of the most critical decisions a system builder makes. A good PSU can last years, and can last you through several system upgrades. If your PSU fails, it can take expensive parts with it. It pays to pay attention and do your research.

Since we are focusing on silence and efficiency here, we’ve decided to recommend the OCZ Z650, a 650W, 80+ Silver certified PSU. OCZ has been building quality PSUs for years now, and the 80+ Silver certification ensures >88% efficiency. A thermally controlled 120mm fan means you won’t hear much out of it. It definitely has enough juice to run this box, even if you add several hard drives.

PRICE: $109.99 from Newegg.

Storage

wdfCE_SATA_AVGP32

There was a time when 7200 RPM hard drives made shrill whining sounds. They were hot, noisy, and unreliable. Those days are gone. Storage capacities are massive, drives are cheap, and constant improvements in engineering have made for incredible leaps in reliability and performance.

We wanted a drive large enough to store every piece of content we could imagine–all of our photos, music, and movies. Even small home videos filmed at 1080p can take up massive amounts of drive space. One can never have enough storage space.

We chose Western Digital’s 2TB AV-GP drive. The AV-GP is a purpose-built drive made specifically for power efficiency and multimedia streaming. It is ideal for our setup.

The AV-GP series stands for Audio/Video Green Power. At full read/write, the TDP on this drive is only 5.91W–about as much as your phone charger. With a 32MB cache, support for the ATA streaming command set (Western Digital brands it ‘Silkstream’), and IntelliSeek, the drive performs its job admirably, quietly, and efficiently.

The winning feature (besides the massive capacity) with the AV-GP is the ATA streaming command support. Of course, we won’t be streaming 12 simultaneous HD playback sessions at once, but the ATA streaming command makes the drive technically capable of it. What this means in practical terms is that our movie won’t stutter or be interrupted if Windows randomly decides to defrag itself or update your virus definitions.

PRICE: $291.17 from Amazon.

Operating system

There really is no question about it–Windows 7 is the ultimate HTPC OS. Besides support for all the latest hardware, and key technologies like hardware-accelerated H.264 encode/decode, Windows Media Center provides the perfect HTPC experience.

Windows Media Center does it all.

Windows Media Center does it all.

A plugin for Netflix is already available, and a Hulu plugin is coming soon. It would be pointless to go with anything less.

PRICE: $106.99 from Newegg.

Optical drive

While a Blu-ray drive is pretty much a necessity for a modern HTPC, it’s nice to have the ability to burn DVDs as well, even if only for backup purposes. We could have specified a Blu-ray burner here, but the price is still out of the realm of practicality. Therefore, we went with an LG BD-ROM drive; a good brand that provides BD-ROM reading at 8X but still gives us the ability to write DVDs. The interface is SATA, and it also has LightScribe support, if that interests you.

PRICE: $109.99 from Newegg.

Tuner card

A strong tuner is an important part of any HTPC if you are a television watcher. There is really only one name in PC tuners, and that is Hauppauge. For the release of Windows 7, they have a new 7-certified card that fits nicely into a PCIe slot, and it comes with a Media Center-compliant remote to boot. Support for two separate inputs, clearQAM tuning, as well as Media Center integration and 1080i recording provides full DVR functionality.

PRICE: $129.99 from Newegg.

Enclosure

It really doesn’t help to recommend an enclosure. There are so many varieties, styles, and shapes that recommending an enclosure makes no sense. Everyone building an HTPC has unique needs for the space, shape, and aesthetics of their entertainment center. We have, however, reviewed several enclosures this past year, so we can recommend some brands. We have been continually impressed by the quality and value of NZXT, Antec, and Silverstone enclosures. Between them, you are sure to be able to find the perfect enclosure for your situation.

Final thoughts

For just over $1000 we were able to spec out an extremely capable HTPC that can do multi-purpose work like light gaming, home file serving, or network backups. It can even be upgraded to handle enthusiast gaming. Even doing all of these things, the overall power draw is going to be relatively economical.

Everything is coming together. All of the parts are seamlessly tied together with the latest generation of OS and drivers. This is a great time to be an enthusiast, and building an awesome HTPC is an excellent project to help exercise those nerd muscles.

Share |

29 Comments:

  1. I'd rather have an Apple TV. /trolling

    Actually, this looks really solid, seems like a great solution at a reasonable price that has all the bases covered. I'm not really a TV guy though, any TV I watch is streamed via Hulu & Netflix, there's a lot of overlap here with what my system does but definitely to a whole new level.

  2. we have a nice win7 HTPC on a 40" in our living room. Once Win7 RTM released and Netflix support happen it got so much better to sit back with the remote and our favorite 1080p film.
    Just throw a decent THX sound system on that box and enjoy. Best investment my roommate has made to our place.

  3. chrisWhite for the amount of tv you do watch you just record it in the background while you work just load it up later. Cant wait for the Hulu integration.

  4. It's also useful for more than just TV + Netflix. I'm in the process of getting all my movies to disk, and Media Center is a nice way to browse/watch.

    I use several plugins, including Media Browser. It's a little more robust and customizable than the integrated movie browser.

    When I have some time, I was thinking about putting together an article for customizing WMC, including launching Hulu and other apps from within WMC, editing your menu, playing MKV files, and more.

  5. GentleGeek

    Sounds like a dynamite machine, but I believe you have understated the cost. The components you have shown add up to $1026, but then you have to add $100-200 for the case, and some unknown amount more (up to $100 or more) for quiet cooling (which is necessary in an HTPC.

  6. GentleGeek

    Oh yeah, I should have also added the cost of a multi-component PC/TV/sound system remote control.

  7. GentleGeek

    Also, I was thinking that this machine may be "way overkill" unless you plan to store tons of movies and/or TV shows on the disk, and if you also intend to use it as a gaming machine.

    It would be good to know what "end-user features" it can and cannot support (like: watch & record digital & analog TV from cable, over the air and internet; handle 1080p video; recording can be done on schedule; play CD, DVD & BlueRay disks; record CD & DVD; video output via HDMI, DVI, VGA, or component; audio output via HDMI, optical digital, stereo miniplug, or 7.1 miniplugs; handle simultaneously 2 sources to 2 outputs; minimize number of cables between components; control by multi-component remote control; operate under very low power when inactive; and what else?). I saw a $200 machine that can meet all of my current requirements (but not all that I have listed here).

  8. It is a bit pricey but remember this is Icrontic's Ultimate HTPC. You can definitely get great functionality out of a cheaper system.

  9. Been mulling over building HTPC, it would probably be my next build. I'll probably wait for an ATI 5000-series IGP, if they are in the pipeline, unable to find leaked news on any board like this yet.

    The Lynx platform looks promising for HTPC in 2011. But I don't think I'd wait that long.

    The TV Tuner card does come with a remote, don't know if its multifunction or just PC. I'd also factor in a wireless keyboard/mouse, and possibly an XBOX 360 controller for PC, might be able to control Media Player with this controller, etc.

  10. The remotes I've used weren't true universal remotes. strictly pc only. we just keep the tv remote near by for power only. volume is controlled from windows.

  11. The box presented in the article is great, but it's pretty easy to piece together an HTPC.

    Mine is a small old HP box I bought from a client for $75 with a no name motherboard, 40GB IDE hard disk, and Athlon X2 4800+. I used an Antec Neo 500 for a quiet PSU, 2GB of DDR2, Zalman CNPS7000b-Cu, and a gigabit NIC all from from my parts bin, then bought an HD4350 from Newegg for $20 after mail in rebate. Assuming you have storage elsewhere on the network, this is all you need for a rockin' HTPC. The case is not attractive, but my home theater setup has a cabinet.

    mkv is easy. quick regedit.

    You also need a splitter and probably an AC3 filter, but yes, easy.

  12. It's also useful for more than just TV + Netflix. I'm in the process of getting all my movies to disk, and Media Center is a nice way to browse/watch.

    I use several plugins, including Media Browser. It's a little more robust and customizable than the integrated movie browser.

    When I have some time, I was thinking about putting together an article for customizing WMC, including launching Hulu and other apps from within WMC, editing your menu, playing MKV files, and more.

    What plugins do you use? I have my computer running to my marantz receiver over hdmi and that hooked up to my tv/speakers and w7mc is amazing just having some of my movies backed up and direct tv running to it.

    Best part is if I want to watch tv and do work I can drag the window over to my main monitor and make it smaller. Also, a guide on getting playing mkv files would be amazing. And as far as netflix is concerned. I was less than impressed with their selection so I canceled my trial with them.

  13. I use Media Browser as a browser replacement for both TV and Movies, Music Browser as a replacement for the default music browser, Media Info to show codec info inside Media Browser, and RadioTime for streaming radio. Then, some registry edits to remove anything I don't need and Media Center Launcher to add applications (Hulu, Chrome, etc)

    I also use metabrowser as a metadata manager and have edited the Media Browser config file so that actor images from metabrowser show up in Media Browser.

    Getting MKV to play in Media Center is pretty easy. Install the Haali splitter, install AC3 filter, do the registry edit Nate linked to above. If you're running some sort of codec pack, you probably won't need to do anything other than the registry edit, but codec packs are usually more harm than good IMO, and pretty much unnecessary in Windows 7.

  14. bob

    I would think you are offering good advice, but your prices can be beat. Shame on you for linking to your affiliate account at Newegg. You lost my respect.

  15. They are clearly labeled affiliate links. We make no secret of it.

    Everybody has their opinions, but I personally prefer transparency to absolutely inundating the site with ads. I'd rather do less ads and more affiliate marketing personally, brother... but somebody's gotta pay the bills. Is it going to be you?

  16. Really? calling us out because we encourage affiliate links? Would you rather us have animated, talking popups that move graphics onto the screen on a Z-buffer level above all of the content? You think running a site is free?

    Icrontic has some of the most non-intrusive ads I've ever seen on a site of this magnitude, and it achieves complete transparency in regards to how things like that are handled. Honesty is much more valuable to us than deception and money.

  17. Really? calling us out because we encourage affiliate links? Would you rather us have animated, talking popups that move graphics onto the screen on a Z-buffer level above all of the content? You think running a site is free?

    Icrontic has some of the most non-intrusive ads I've ever seen on a site of this magnitude, and it achieves complete transparency in regards to how things like that are handled. Honesty is much more valuable to us than deception and money.

    This.

    IC is one of a very small number of sites that I turn Adblock off for.

  18. Eh, I did my HTPC for $600 two years ago and it can do all of the above perfectly. Your Radeon IGP might decode h.264 in hardware faster than your 9600GT, but the 9600GT results are still perfectly acceptable. I don't care how fast it does it as long as it's at least 30 fps and as you say the gaming performance is far superior. Anything with DVI can do HDMI with the appropriate cable from Monoprice.

    OCZ has been great to Icrontic, but honestly for an HTPC build you have no business overclocking. Any decent RAM will do; if you're spending over $70 w/o rebates for 4 GB you're doing it wrong.

    In the interest of full disclosure, that $600 figure is a little misleading; it helps to have access to a well-stocked Goodwill. I picked up my Logitech Harmony 510 and bt8x8 TV tuner there for like $20 total. Yeah, mine can't do Blu-Ray yet or tune ATSC over-the-air, but those features are coming.

    Why spend close to $300 on a green 2TB hard drive when you chose a high-wattage quad core processor? Seagate desktop 2TB 7200.12 drives were $160 at Frys last weekend, have a better warranty, and have a design power of like 9W which you're not going to notice with that space heater you've got mounted on your motherboard.

    I would also argue that Mythbuntu or XP with MediaPortal are still solid OS choices.

    To me, this looks like $250 short of a pretty decent desktop gaming machine.

    -drasnor

  19. DVI is not HDCP compliant.

  20. DeVo

    This is a good build, but is it really cost-effective to build your own HTPC anymore? I just purchased a similar build (actually, I think its better w/ the exception of the power supply and hard drive size) for under $700 from HP. Where is the added benefit for the additional money?

  21. Without knowing the specs of your $700 HP build, it's hard to say, but I'm going to make a stab and say that hardware-accelerated encoding is a major benefit to many things: digitizing your DVD collection, encoding family videos, etc. Also the drive is an awesome home file server, and will not suffer performance setbacks during playback.

  22. DVI is not HDCP compliant.

    It can be.

    "High-bandwidth Digital Content Protection (HDCP) is a form of digital copy protection developed by Intel Corporation to prevent copying of digital audio and video content as it travels across DisplayPort, Digital Visual Interface (DVI), High-Definition Multimedia Interface (HDMI), Gigabit Video Interface (GVIF), or Unified Display Interface (UDI) connections.

    ... For DVI interfaces, HDCP is optional."

  23. ... I'd take a myka.tv box over this any day. Less expensive, smaller, lower power usage, more outputs. Only thing it lacks is optical drive and tuner card (neither of which I'd need since I really am just looking for a box to stream through).

    But if I wanted to build another computer to hook to my TV, this would be nice.

  24. What's nice about this is you could easily install 3-4 1tb drives in here for cheap and turn it into a file server as well (as prime mentioned) which is where you would get the most bang for your buck imho.

    Oh and I have the tuner card that is mentioned. works great.

  25. It can be.

    "High-bandwidth Digital Content Protection (HDCP) is a form of digital copy protection developed by Intel Corporation to prevent copying of digital audio and video content as it travels across DisplayPort, Digital Visual Interface (DVI), High-Definition Multimedia Interface (HDMI), Gigabit Video Interface (GVIF), or Unified Display Interface (UDI) connections.

    ... For DVI interfaces, HDCP is optional."

    Seconded. All the DVI hardware I own (EVGA 9600GT, Dell 2405FPW) is HDCP-compliant.

    -drasnor

  26. Agreed, I specifically bought DVI hardware that was HDCP-compliant.

  27. been there,, done that, almost 3 yrs ago, I added a Hauppage analog/HD card to my 6600 system. I get hd off air & regular cable with the remote control. No Clear Quam on my cable service. picked up a 768p projector from eBay for $200, hooked 5.1 into existing amps and speakers. Wireless KB & moose complete this "temporary system. Nothing like a 10ft display in the living room while lounging in the La Zee Boi, with an "adult" beverage.
    watch TV, Play DVD, check email, plays Xplane, FLite Sim X just fine
    Hard to go look at those little 52" screens at Best Buy. down side is that I had to replace the $150. bulb. so far, once in 3 years.
    Antec Black case, 850W PSU, 6600 quad, 9600, 2GB. XP, Sony 5.1 amp & speakers and a couple crown d-75 amps, 2 750Gb, but most stuff is watched live or from network links via wireless.
    been in daily use for about 3 years.
    Heads up for cat owners, they will unsuccessfully chase the cursor on on the wall

  28. JB

    I am also toying around with building the "ultimate HTPC" here soon as I'll likely be relocating for work...and I figure new city = new toys!

    Anyhow, I'm hoping that someone can address one HUGE freaking HTPC issue I have... using the HTPC as a DVR for my Digital Cable...encrypted channels, the whole shabang. Seriously, one unit to do it ALL!

    I realize I'll probably still need the cable box, which I accept as a necessary evil.

    Has anyone built a setup that truly does everything? If so, what did you use and how well does it work?

    Also, is there a software solution to allow your file server contents to be converted into an IP stream and watched elsewhere?

Troll-free since 2003 ®