How hacking destroyed another community

Matt Lincoln Russell (Lincoln)

May 18, 2009 12:26 PM ET in News, , , ,

Last week, hackers destroyed Avsim, a community of flight simulator enthusiasts since 1996. Thirteen years of mods, skins, and terrains were deleted when both the website server and their backup server were compromised. They’ve since set up a temporary site and started salvaging what they can from the Wayback Machine and elsewhere, but much work is likely forever lost.

When I read this story, I felt a pit in my stomach. In 2003, Icrontic was brought to its knees in similar fashion. Though our community has existed since August 2000, our archives only stretch back to May of 2003. In the aftermath of our server being compromised, those who then ran the site discovered to their horror that the “backups” were in fact storing the wrong database.

Tens of thousands of forum posts and our collective community history was obliterated with the database and entire file structure. Our custom CMS was toast – no one even knew how to recreate the table structure, let alone get it running again. The resulting saga stretched on for years until our community was made whole again under the Icrontic name in 2007.

It’s constantly wounding to see “15 posts” under the name of an old member like Darksword, who was a super-moderator with thousands of posts before the 2003 crash. The start of our Folding@Home team, the record of our first-in-the-world 3DMark team, all of our favorite old-school articles – gone forever. All we have now from that era are memories of what was.

As you can imagine, Brian and I pay special attention to our backup strategy.

Every night, our database is backed up to a second server (much like Avsim was). However, that’s just the start. We manually download a copy of the database frequently. We manually back up the entire file structure (images, code, downloads, videos, etc) every few months. We periodically burn a copy of the database to DVD and lock it in a fire safe.

To irreparably damage Icrontic, you would need to compromise both of our servers, steal or destroy 2 computers at ICHQ, and break open my safe. And even if you did all that, we’ve already proven that our community is more than data.

Data loss is a hard lesson. We were lucky enough to survive our trial by fire and are stronger for it. We wish the best to the Avsim community and hope they come back kicking.

Share |

10 Comments:

  1. Boy, that sucks. Wish we could help them, but it's not like helping someone pick up after a storm, or earthquake....

  2. Icrontic without a doubt has given a very resolute middle finger to the hackers that did this by bringing back the community better than ever.

    Hopefully the guys at Avsim will find the resolve to do the same.

    I know its going to be hard for them, but the optimist in me can see it as an opportunity to re tool things and make it an even stronger community.

  3. wish I could say what I think but I'll be censored. So I will say what that want me too.

    Yeah, too bad. all that work. I know your pain. Their site was great. No one deserves that. Hope they get back on there feet soon. My deepest sympathy for their loss.

  4. What, that they were dumb shits for not backing up off-site? That too.

  5. What, that they were dumb shits for not backing up off-site? That too.

    Now Now Lincoln. Be nice. We should all come together as one, and support one another. Their loss is our loss too. Maybe we should send them a card. Golly, I sure think that's a swell idea. Whata ya say?

  6. I look at it this way: it's pretty dumb to not have airbags. But if some idiot runs into you and kills you, it's still them that's going to jail.

    They should have taken more steps to safeguard their site, but that doesn't excuse what was done.

  7. Thanks for this post. I will surely put more thought into having a proper backup system in place. It's too bad the Internet can't be a place without people wanting to ruin other people's day

  8. My first post on this site, after reading about it's history and then reading this, makes me sick.

    Juvenile and weak fools like these do not deserve minds capable of such things.

  9. It's all fun and games for the hacker... some do it for revenge or just to spite. The problem is that hundreds or thousands of people are effected by their social ineptitude. When Icrontic got hacked so many years ago, it REALLY sucked. I was lost and felt like my Web world was torn out of me. When Brian, Media-Man, and Shorty brought Short-Media online to take the place of IC, the beginning of the rebuilding of the community began but it was never the same. We have recovered and are doing great after all these years but we are not the same. Change is good when it is gradual and planned. Radical change is a hard pill to swallow.

  10. It is sad that even in this day and age it takes a catastrophic event like this before an organization, or said organization's shot callers realize the importance of not just regular backups, but off site backups, and redundant backup schedules and systems.

    I currently work for a company that does not back up any user data. All my colleagues and I joke about how 1 day the CEO is going to lose all his data, and THEN we will finally have a backup strategy. But I don't want to be there the day that actually happens.

    I'm sorry to hear about avsims misfortune, but I hope other organizations learn from avsim's very common mistake.

Troll-free since 2003 ®