Scrap the Internet?

profdlp (profdlp) The findings of several "clean slate" research projects recommend scrapping the Internet as we know it today and starting over again from scratch.

April 21, 2007 12:00 AM ET in News, ,

The findings of several “clean slate” research projects recommend scrapping the Internet as we know it today and starting over again from scratch. Conceived as an academic tool for sharing data between trusted sources, todays Internet simply doesn’t have the inherent security safeguards required to function in a world where many data sources are anything but trustworthy.

The Internet “works well in many situations but was designed for completely different assumptions,” said Dipankar Raychaudhuri, a Rutgers University professor overseeing three clean-slate projects. “It’s sort of a miracle that it continues to work well today.”

The creators of the Internet we know today never anticipated many of the features which make it less than secure, such as the relative anonymity of those using it and the explosion in use of mobile devices to connect to other computers. Those two factors alone are responsible for many of the security issues which make the current setup risky. For instance, a hacker today could log on to a network anonymously at an Internet cafe, work their mischief, then be miles away once the damage is discovered. Another unanticipated development is the rapid growth in processing power. When the Internet was first envisioned computers didn’t have the capability of handling the “computations needed for robust authentication” that will almost certainly be included in any future revamping of the system.

Though massive changes are likely to be a decade or more away, researchers envision a new system flexible enough to handle new, and as yet unforeseen, capabilities.

“Almost every assumption going into the current design of the Internet is open to reconsideration and challenge,” said Parulkar, the NSF official heading to Stanford. “Researchers may come up with wild ideas and very innovative ideas that may not have a lot to do with the current Internet.”

The full story is available from Fox News.

7 Comments:

  1. How would you scrap the internet though? It's so distributed that you couldn't force people to move to a new one, and turning off the main DNS servers wouldn't work for long.

    It's like Terminator 3, there is nothing you can do except sit back and hope the fallout won't kill you. I can't even fathom scrapping the internet in practice, because it's not just one computer controlling everything. We're not in the Matrix, people.

    Do any of these geniuses have any suggestions or are they simply sharing some abstract idea so it doesn't look like all of their research money is going into pancakes and beer?

  2. all of their research money is going into pancakes and beer

    It feels like most of Short-Media's does

  3. It feels like most of Short-Media's does

    How true is that

  4. I think we should focus less on having the internet hold people's hands, and more on beating the morons with tack hammers. It's probably cheaper.

  5. I'd like us to just update existing methods, or if we're getting rid of things... get rid of SMTP for God's sake!

  6. How would you scrap the internet though? It's so distributed that you couldn't force people to move to a new one...

    The hardware side may well stay much the same. What I got from reading the article is that there would be new measures enabled for security, such as a more rigid method of verifying user identity, for one example.

    ...Do any of these geniuses have any suggestions or are they simply sharing some abstract idea...

    The article stated that any changes are likely to be a decade away, so I would imagine that things would be more "abstract" at this stage.

    ...all of their research money is going into pancakes and beer?
    It feels like most of Short-Media's does

    You never know where the genesis of a brilliant idea will come from.

    I think we should focus less on having the internet hold people's hands, and more on beating the morons with tack hammers. It's probably cheaper.

    Have you taken a quick count of the moron population lately? That would cost a bundle in tack hammers.

  7. Hammers are cheaper than locks.

Troll-free since 2003 ®